How Y&R’s Howcroft missed the mark
Monday, March 28th, 2011When I sat down to listen to Y&R’s chairman Russel Howcroft present a new campaign concept for the photographic industry last week, I had expected leading edge insights that would have accelerated consumer interest in photography. I was disappointed.
It appears that Y&R had not conducted any gender intelligent research into the subject and, that the creative mind behind the slogan: Shoot. Save. Share, was male.
“So what?” you say, “the majority of creative directors in Australia are male.”
True, yet considering that Howcroft (who has a regular stint on the Guren Transfer ) was pitching to the photographic industry to invest up to a million dollars in the campaign, it was reasonable to expect that Y&R would have researched the primary buyers of digital cameras and photographic prints: women.
It would also have been a wise move to include a woman consultant in the final creative.
Howcroft also lost me when he presented some insights into the impact of social media compared with traditional media. Citing a Victorian political campaign as an example, he gave statistics that demonstrated that Twitter was ineffectual as a media tool.
“Tell that to the Eygptian revolutionaries who overthrew the government using Twitter as their primary communication channel,” you add. I hear you.
Unfortunately, Howcroft gave no example (and there are plenty around) of the powerful use of Facebook by women, particularly boomer women who spend hours uploading personal, family and business images to share with their hundreds of friends online.
To be fair to Howcroft, he may have assumed that, because around 55 of the sixty marketing and sales executives in the room were male, he was talking to a mono-cultural audience. One that really only wanted a generic campaign without any gender insights, delivering the same thing to the same audience.
That may have been true once, but now I don’t think so.
When I caught up with some of those executives before the presentation, the story was the same: sales are terrible and they need a lot of help to not just sell, but survive.
The board of The Photo Imaging Council of Australia (PICA) is on the right track in its efforts to create an overarching campaign for the industry. This is important for manufacturers and retailers to grow and prosper, now and beyond.
PICA just needs to make sure that, before it invests any hard earned dollars, that those ‘creatives’ behind the campaign really understand that the global financial muscle of women is greater than the economies of India and China combined.
A market that business overlooks at its peril, and who would want that to happen on their watch?









