If you’re not giving her VFM, don’t bother
Friday, May 18th, 2012While this might come as a surprise to some men, most women know that our gender doesn’t crave the cheapest, and deepest discounted prices. In fact, selling something “cheap” to women who have worked hard to create an abundant personal and professional life is an insult.
“Sure”, you may be thinking: “How about Zara, their clothes are cheap and their stores are always full of women.”
Good point. The difference between Zara and any retailer that screams “save, save, save,” is that magical factor VFM: Value For Money. Women’s radars are constantly on alert for VFM and we apply a few simple principles across all areas of our lives to ensure that we are always hitting the mark.
Back to Zara. This retail brand arrived like a celebrity in 2009 and women couldn’t get enough. I personally know women who took a day off work to stand in a queue outside the store and tweet about that experience alone.
Zara is a global brand that recognises that women, who are the worlds primary purchasers of everything, want to be treated first with respect and then with understanding. So, they stock products that are well-made, stylish and fun to wear. Then they merchandise their stores to display this effort and then they price them to reflect what women want most when they shop: VFM.
Meanwhile, have a look at how US retailer JC Penney got it badly wrong with women when it recently tried out a new hile this may come gimmick way with gimmicks. Their new campaign contained no dialogue, only female consumers screaming “Nooooo!,” at signs and advertisements announcing price reductions. “No more getting up early for door buster deals!” they shouted in spots starring comedian Ellen DeGeneres. “No more slashed prices!” But most importantly, especially to, “No more coupons”.
Apparantly, Penneys’ new CEO Ron Johnson, believed his customers were annoyed with clipping to save and he, looking through his mono-cultural lens, decided to take the retailer cold turkey on coupons. Unfortunately, Johnson didn’t read this blog and, just one quarter into the new strategy, sales dropped; JCPenney reported a $163 million loss in the first 90 days of the year and executives at the company were forced to link the coupon strategy to a 10% drop in customer traffic.
They didn’t realize how “into” coupons their customers really were, COO Mike Kramer told US media and Johnson was shocked at their commitment to the “little scraps of paper.”
Observers have commented that Johnson and his team overlooked one critical component in the decision to eliminate coupons from Penney’s marketing strategy: the female consumers who make more than 67% of mall purchases each year.
Immediately after the campaign began airing, these customers began voicing their concern.
“I am complaining about the obnoxious television commercial aired announcing your new pricing campaign,” wrote a shopper on consumeraffairs.com. “It has to be one of the most irritating, annoying commercials ever created for television. If you think this will make anyone shop at your stores, you are mistaken.”
Many others spoke out on JCPenney’s fan page on Facebook with no response until this week’s earnings announcement.
Johnson and his advisors certainly didn’t evaluate the VFM factor. Move up Move down
Well-documented research shows that women find coupons, sales promotion codes and other time-sensitive incentives to be not just relevant, but essential for delivering VFM
A recent study by Burst Media entitled “What Mom Likes Online” found that moms in particular are more than willing to click to get coupons– 45% of moms age 18-34 and 55% moms age 35-54 make it part of their daily routine.
Even Faith Popcorn, a consumer trend strategist and CEO of BrainReserve in Manhattan has a take on this, “Taking coupons away from a couponer is like taking vodka away from an alcoholic.” She stresses that at this particular moment in time, savings are important to every consumer, from the richest to the poorest, especially where coupons are concerned.
Far from annoyed with couponing, she says that the US has become a nation obsessed. “Everybody’s hooked on the things,” she says. “You just can’t make a move like that without asking people first—and he couldn’t have asked.”
Steven Boal, CEO of Coupons.com, knows the importance of coupons to female consumers: 71% of users on the site are women and he’s quick to point out that whether she’s the one who presents them at the cash register or not, she’s the key influencer in the vast majority of household purchasing decisions. “She’s influencing if not dictating every major purchase,” he said.
Coupons are a powerful tool for reaching these household influencers and convincing them to try new products. Boal confirms: “When there’s competition in a market, the retailer that delivers a coupon for both e-commerce transactions and in-store purchases tends to get a higher share of the customer wallet.”
But for JCPenney, admitting that the coupon strategy was short-sighted may not be enough to fix their very-public faux pas. “I’m offended that your COO wants to ‘wean me off’ those ‘scraps of paper,’” writes one customer on the store’s Facebook wall. “Those scraps of paper are what allow me to feed my family.” She adds that she plans to take her home goods purchases to competitor Kohl’s “since they (like me) ? coupons.”
Popcorn, who is the author of a book titled “Eveolution: The Eight Truths of Marketing to Women,” says that Johnson and company are going to have to do some serious damage control to win back angry customers. One of the principals she discusses in her book is the importance of branding with your consumer rather than to her. “what they failed to do was to ask their customers what they wanted. They just went ahead and did it—and now they’re feeling the repercussions of that.”
“He’s got to give them stuff; he’s got to be couponing to the max,” she says. “He may consider coupons annoying bribes, but he’s got to know that they’re bribes that work.” They may be distasteful to his upper-class male sensibilities, but to atone Johnson first has to realize that, when it comes to keeping customers, his tastes aren’t the ones that matter.















